1.5.1.2

Manual Assign

Select reviewers in the table of your program's committee and reviewers, select papers, and assign them at once. The reviewer gets the review task, a notification and one email about the new papers right away.

Last updated: 2026-11-12

Purpose

Manual Assign is the hand made way to assign reviewers. You select one or more reviewers, select the papers they should review, and click Assign papers. The assignment takes effect at once: the reviewer gets a reviewer role in the program if they had none, a review task and a notification. Each reviewer also gets one email listing their new papers, from the program's New assignments template, the same email Assign All Suggested sends: it comes from your program's committee, replies go to the program's contact email, and a copy lands in their Webmail. The result says who was emailed.

When you use it

  • To give a paper a specific expert.
  • To fill papers that Auto Assign left short of reviewers.
  • When your program is small enough that matching by hand is quicker.

Walkthrough

  1. 1

    Open Review → Reviewer Assignment → Manual Assign.

  2. 2

    Select reviewers. The table lists everyone who can review in this program (or sub-program): its chairs, Senior Area Chairs, Area Chairs, PC Members, Reviewers and External Reviewers. You are listed too, so you can review papers yourself. Each row shows the person's email, organization, role and how many papers they already review here. Check the box of each person to assign, or the box in the header to select everyone shown. Type in the box above to filter by name, email, organization or role. Click a column heading to sort by it, and again to reverse the order (Assigned sorts by how many papers; people without an organization go last). The table shows 10 people a page; the header box selects the people on the page shown, and selections stay when you change page. Members whose Reviews Papers is Off (set in Committee) are hidden; select Show N members with Reviews Papers Off to list them. Assigning papers to one of them asks first, because it turns their Reviews Papers On again.

  3. 3

    Select submissions. Search by paper number or title, then select the submissions. Submissions that already have enough assigned reviewers are not listed: enough is the number for their category (Reviewers per paper by category), else Reviewers per paper. Reviewers who declined do not count, and a submission you already selected stays listed. A line under the search says how many are not listed; click Show them to list them too (for example to add one more reviewer), and Hide them to go back. The columns are those of Assignments & Progress: Submission (the paper number, with the title below), Submitted (when it was submitted, in the program's time zone, with Late under it when that was after its due date; hover for the due date), Type (Paper, Abstract or Proposal), Category and Reviewers. Click a column heading to sort by it, and again to reverse the order (Reviewers sorts by how many; submissions without a date or category go last). Each reviewer box shows the reviewer number with the name below, coloured by where the review stands (green assigned, grey waiting, amber draft saved, red late, purple submitted; a reviewer who declined is grey and struck through). Hover a box for the name, email and the review's stage and due date. Beside the paper number, a mark shows submissions a selected reviewer is already assigned to or has a conflict with. With several reviewers selected, the mark shows how many of them. The table shows 10 submissions a page, paged the same way as the reviewers. Click the eye icon beside the paper number to read its Submission Details in a window over the dimmed page. Drag the window by its title bar anywhere on the screen, and close it with the × button, Esc, or a click outside it. The window is for reading: Edit, Email Authors and Delete are not in it (open the paper in a new tab from the title bar for those), and links in it open in a new tab. Prev and Next in the title bar (with the paper's place, for example 3 of 42) move to the previous or next paper of the table, in its current order and across all its pages, without closing the window. The ← and → keys do the same.

  4. 4

    Click Assign papers. A window you can drag by its title bar shows the email each reviewer gets about their new papers (the New assignments template), as in Assign All Suggested: edit the subject and message under Edit, and pick a reviewer under Preview to see exactly what they get. Clear Email each reviewer their new papers to assign without an email; the review task and the notification still go. Click Assign and email (or Assign). Every selected reviewer is assigned to every selected paper. A summary lists, per reviewer, what was assigned, what was already assigned, whether they were emailed, and anything that was blocked.

Tips

Past reviewer scores

A badge such as ★ 4.5 · 3 next to a name means chairs of 3 other programs rated this person as a reviewer, 4.5 of 5 on average (an award icon means one of them marked them outstanding). A program where they wrote more reviews counts more, up to 10 reviews. Hover it for the details. Only the average and the number of programs show: never who rated them or their notes. Your own program's scores are in Assignments & Progress, View by Reviewer. Only those who manage the program see the badge.

Max papers

The Assigned column shows each person's papers in this program, every type, and their limit (for example 7 / 8): their own Max Papers from Committee, else the program's Max Papers Per Reviewer. Assigning past the limit asks first; click Assign anyway to go ahead. Auto Assign then gives them no more papers.

When they were emailed

Under the number, Emailed and a date show when the person last got a New assignments email (from Manual Assign or Assign All Suggested), with how many there were in brackets; hover it for who sent it and how many papers it listed. Click it for every assignment email to that person: when, by whom, whether it was sent, and its papers. Red Not emailed means that email failed; amber means its outcome is unknown, so check their Webmail before sending again.

Conflicts

A soft conflict (for example the same institution) stops the assignment and lists the papers. Select Override soft conflicts and assign again to go ahead. An author can never review their own paper; that conflict cannot be overridden.

Open the Program Chair Console